do I look silly in this brace? is it helping in any real way? It just may be. Hard to say and yet it seems to be doing so.
More chiro yesterday with T Fagan. Enjoyed it more and accepted it much more, willing to agree-see that it is doing something that works, may work. Who cares if machine metaphors work or not. The movie at the heart of Bablyon Berlin last night was all about machine-man, man-machine. Boris is the one who helped me see more clearly both his sort of massage on muscle and tendon and chiro's work on skeletal structures. Plus seeing Dr Claire about feet and having him support barefoot shoes. World is changing indeed and I can see how all of these body works have come a long way under the wisdom experiences of people living in their bodies as they have been trying to do for a while now. This coming week I will check in with the PT crew at Speare to see what their take on things is and to see if they can help with my lifting and chairing routines and tasks.
Should I give up on the Rouse? check on youtube first to see how it is pronounced. am on page 412 of 1200 some pages. Saw one guy on youtube say read this if nothing else and yet could hear the warnings in his voice too --- did not go on in the video. let me look at one star peeps on goodreads. You who know me are saying uh oh if he's searching for one star confirmations is that a good sign? remember he's not really a reader or even an eng major, he's an architect who got railroaded into teaching eng for all the wrong reasons and why does he even bother to read anything? these days. if he did restricted geometric paintings for some years why would he like 1200 page novels?
well look at this first one I landed on and she "Roman Clodia" also gave up on page 400 -- and her complaints sound right on!!! "DNF about 400 pages in - spoilers below
This is undoubtedly an ambitious and impressive project but for this reader the 1200+ pages just didn't justify their length. The two strands of personal (Maur) and political/military (Allerdyce) unravel in tandem but there was way too much repetition for me: Allerdyce learns about the supernatural 'Rouse' and all the appurtenances and then tells Maur about them. Neither are really characters in a rounded sense, they are functions within the text, and so I didn't have any emotional connection to them that might have locked me in beyond wanting the understand the cosmic mystery at the heart of the story. And there is a metaphysical mystery here: the use by the military of The Rouse to awaken the dead and literally use them as a capitalist resource in imperial wars across the globe while covering up the secrets in their archive.
I guess the issue for me is that anyone already well-versed in Marxist critiques of imperialism, the military-industrial complex, and the imagery of the dead as a haunting exposure of authoritarianism, will be ahead of the game here and the literary qualities weren't enough on their own to keep me in this dark world through so many pages.
There are so many tropes of the hidden underworld in literature from the Odyssey and Aeneid, mythologies of an underworld that exist in many cultures and even the use of magic in Harry Potter (the apports reminded me of the teleportation devices in Harry Potter, also everyday objects) that it's hard for me to find this revelatory. Of course, Mieville deliberately resists any kind of heroic good-wins-out resolution but given where we are in late-stage capitalism, that's hardly a surpise.
Individual readers will find their own intertexts here: I was especially taken by the idea of a colonial river being a conduit back to the Thames, surely an allusion to the end of Heart of Darkness where Conrad connects the Congo to the Thames, another piercing exposure and condemnation of imperialism that makes use of an existential vision of 'the horror! the horror!'. I was also thinking about Mariana Enriquez and the way she uses the paranormal such as in the streets of her cities crowded with the jostling shades of the disappeared to make political points.
So my 3-star rating isn't meant to be a negative review of this book, just an indication of why I tired of it after 400 pages - I skipped straight to the end to see where this goes and that was enough for me. If the book had been 400-500 pages in total, I would have finished it, but it became exhausting, feeling bogged down in Maur's strand and I was feeling diminishing returns." this was three Stars
Don’t get me wrong. That sounds amazing, but what does it mean?
That was my biggest problem with this novel: it is incredibly ambitious and the genius behind it is apparent, but as a reader I was left confused and frustrated. As someone who has loved previous works by Miéville, I was ready for this to be a new favourite. I was ready to dedicate time and focus, trusting that the pay off would be worth it.
Alas, I dragged myself through more than half of this book, grappling with a slow pace, a dense, mostly unexciting plot, unlikable yet complex characters, and a frustration that I’m not ‘clever’ enough to get it.
I’m sure this book will be a masterpiece to many. I’m sure critics will find it incredibly impressive and genre-defying.
I felt like I had beaten over the head with a bloated 1,300 book whose supernatural elements are as vague as shapes in the dark.
One of my biggest disappointments in recent years, but I acknowledge this is a VERY personal opinion."
And to add insult-to-injury, a late prose poem even channels my hitherto least favourite Goldsmiths novel, the padded-out Ducks, Newburyport (although the proof-setter had lost the energy to add the signature semi-colons):"
No comments:
Post a Comment